·

Cheapest, Middle or Premium: How to Choose Your Price Position vs Competitors

Cheapest, Middle or Premium: How to Choose Your Price Position vs Competitors

To choose a price position vs competitors, pick one per category, not one for the whole store. Be cheapest where shoppers compare on price alone. Sit near the market average for most products. Price above the market only where you offer what rivals do not. Each position needs its own mix of margin and volume.

A position is a promise to your buyers. If you pick it by accident, you keep the costs of that promise without the benefits.

What are the three price positions?

A price position is where your price sits against the same product in other stores. The price index measures it: 100 means you equal the market average, 90 means you are 10% below it.

  • Cheapest: at or near the lowest price in the market. You win buyers who search for the best deal.
  • Middle: close to the market average, the zone of competitive pricing. You are never the reason a buyer leaves.
  • Premium: clearly above the average. This is premium pricing, and it only holds if buyers see a reason to pay more.

How do the three positions compare?

Each position wins sales in a different way, and each has a different weak spot. Read across the rows before you pick.

CheapestMiddlePremium
Wins the sale withThe lowest priceA fair price and good serviceService, advice or choice
Costs youMargin on every orderSome sales to cheaper rivalsSome sales to everyone else
NeedsLow costs and high volumeSteady tracking of the averageA visible reason to pay more
Main riskA price warDrifting without noticingRivals catching up on service
Smart Price strategyAggressiveBalancedPremium

The middle is the default for a reason. It asks the least of your business. The other two positions pay off only when you can supply what they need.

How many sales does each position need?

More than most sellers expect for the cheapest position, and fewer for premium. Here is an illustrative example in USD. A kitchen store sells a blender that costs $60 per order, including fees and shipping. The market average is $100. At $100, the store sells 90 a month and earns $3,600.

  • Cheapest at $90 (index 90): $30 profit per sale, so it needs 120 sales to earn the same. That is a third more.
  • Middle at $100 (index 100): $40 per sale, 90 sales.
  • Premium at $120 (index 120): $60 per sale, so 60 sales are enough. It can lose a third of its buyers and still earn the same.
Monthly sales to earn $3,600Blender, cost $60 per orderCheapest, at $90120 salesMiddle, at $10090 salesPremium, at $12060 salesIllustrative example, USD
Illustrative example, USD: a 10% lower price needs a third more sales to earn the same profit.

A 10% cut must win a third more sales just to stand still. That gap is why always being the cheapest store can stop paying. Premium has the opposite risk: it works until buyers stop seeing the reason. Here is when to hold a premium and when to step down.

How do you choose a price position vs competitors for each category?

Ask four questions per category, not per store. Picture a kitchen appliance store with about a dozen rivals on each product.

  1. Do buyers compare the exact same model across stores? If yes, price matters most.
  2. How many strong rivals sell it? Many strong rivals make a premium hard to hold.
  3. What do you add that rivals do not? Fast delivery, setup advice or bundles can carry a higher price.
  4. Can your margin carry the volume a lower price needs? Do the sum above before you cut.

The answers often differ by category. Blenders are sold by model number in many stores, so the store prices them low. Cookware sits in the middle. Espresso machines come with setup advice, so the store prices them above the market. To keep several positions in one catalogue, see mixing price positions by category. Category, brand and store reports let you check each one apart.

Which Smart Price strategy fits each position?

BlackAha Smart Price gives three recommended prices per product, recalculated daily from the competitor prices you track. Aggressive is the lowest of the three, to win the sale. Balanced is the default, for margin and position at once. Premium is the highest of the three, for margin.

Pick a strategy, and Smart Price sorts your products into “to raise”, “on target” and “to lower”. For product-level choices, see matching a Smart Price strategy to each product. To act on the lists, read about turning recommendations into price changes you trust and working through the to-raise list in batches. You can also use a Smart Price tier inside your pricing rules. Know the cases where you should ignore a suggested price, and how to price products with no recommendation yet.

How BlackAha helps

BlackAha.com tracks competitor prices for online stores and helps you set your own. My Store Price Ranking shows your position on each product, from Cheapest to Highest price. Product Price Index shows how far you are from the market average. Smart Price tells you how many percent you are above or below the strategy you chose. Dynamic Pricing can then keep each category at its position with rules and guardrails.

Key takeaways

  • Choose a price position per category, not one for the whole store.
  • The middle asks the least of your business. Cheapest and premium each need something extra.
  • In the illustrative example, a 10% lower price needed a third more sales to earn the same.
  • A premium holds only while buyers can see the reason to pay more.
  • Aggressive, Balanced and Premium in Smart Price match the three positions.

Frequently asked questions

Is it better to be the cheapest store?

Only if your costs are low and your volume is high. In the illustrative example, a 10% lower price needed a third more sales just to earn the same profit.

Can I use different price positions in one store?

Yes, and most stores should. Price low where buyers compare the same model, sit near the average for most products, and price higher where you add service or advice.

How do I know my current price position?

Compare your price with the market average for each product. A price index of 100 means you match the average. My Store Price Ranking groups each product from Cheapest to Highest price.

Which Smart Price strategy should I start with?

Balanced is the default and fits most products. Move a category to Aggressive or Premium once you know what that position needs.

Choose one category this week and decide its position on purpose. You can try BlackAha to see where your prices sit today.

Keep reading